Bethesda, OH
43719 · Bethesda, OH has a HavenScore of 48 — growth is the soft spot — population, income, and price trends point the wrong way.
At the ZIP's typical value, the estimated monthly payment takes 25% of the local median income (Zillow, US Census ACS). The buyer/seller gauge leans narrowly toward buyers, a lean that began this month. Typical values moved lower over the last 90 days (Zillow ZHVI).
Saved ZIPs on Haven get an email when the score moves 5+ points as monthly data lands, when the market gauge flips between buyers and sellers, when its valuation read moves against the model value, or when distress jumps in a week.
Zillow ZHVI peaked at $151,347 in Nov 2025; the latest value is -4.0% from that peak, 8 months on. Since January 2019 it is +37.8%. The sharpest 12-month move was -2.2%, ending Jan 2020.
This ZIP has fewer than 5,000 residents, so it isn’t ranked against larger markets. The HavenScore is shown for reference.
Buyer view active — Leans harder on affordability and downside risk.
Score inputs below recompute for this view
Snapshot
Numbers at a glance, with a year of history under each
Place
What it is like to live here, and what could flood or burn
Bands are each source’s own · tick marks the national median ZIP · not blended into the score
Tract-level rolled up to ZIP · not a property-level rating · no future-year projection · refreshed annually (Dec 2025 release) · county tick = median of 13 scored ZIPs in Belmont County
Everyday prices in the Wheeling metro run 12% below the US average (BEA Regional Price Parities, 2024).
Rents in the index run 49% below the US average.
$75,000 at US-average prices buys what $66,250 buys here.
Metro-level index, US = 100 · 2024 · the Wheeling metro, not this ZIP alone
What drives the score
Five pillars, each scored 0–100
Market signals
Tailwinds and headwinds right now
- Affordable vs. income2.9× income — below the national median
- Limited new supplyOnly 0.0 permits per 1,000 — supply constrained
- Fast-moving market16 days on market — selling quickly
- Population outflow-5.8% net — people leaving
- Potentially overvalued38% above historical price-to-income
- Widespread price cuts40% of listings cutting price
Market conditions
Leaning Buyer
Conditions are easing in buyers' favor. The score reads more negotiation room than balanced.
Cycle read. Softening: prices 0.0% over the trailing year, with the market leaning toward buyers.
The Zillow figure is a smoothed index of typical value, not a list price; the Redfin figures are closed sales for the month shown.
Momentum check
What's changed in the last 90 days
Trend
Where it's been
Forecast
Where it's heading
The HavenScore Forecast Model (v1) projects this ZIP’s median value at 3-, 6-, and 12-month horizons, with 80% prediction intervals; Pro adds 24- and 36-month horizons.
Monthly cost
What you'd owe each month
20% down · 30-yr fixed · 6.71% · tax 1.59%
Rent data isn’t published for this ZIP, so we can’t compute a rent-vs-buy gap.
Insurance uses the average homeowners premium insurers reported for this ZIP in 2022, $1,048 a year (Treasury Federal Insurance Office).
25%of the ZIP’s median income at the median value ($1,030/mo against $49,700 · Zillow, Freddie Mac PMMS, US Census ACS). Your own marker appears once you set an income or price in the calculator below.
Median home value ÷ median household income · Zillow ZHVI, US Census ACS · under 4× has historically been comfortable
Run the numbers
Your price, rate, down payment and income
Like for like: a 3-bedroom here rents for about $1,250 a month (HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, FY2026) against a typical 3-bedroom value of $181k (Zillow ZHVI by bedroom) — a 8.3% gross rent yield.
Not subscribing? The four-page report for ZIP 43719 is $19 once, no subscription. Haven is $12/mo while you hunt — cancel when you close.
Comparable ZIPs
Same shape, lower entry
ZIPs the score groups near 43719 on Affordability and Growth — sorted by lowest median value. Each tile names what the lower price trades: commute (ACS), walkability band (EPA) and hazard rating (FEMA).
- Saves $49k
- Similar commute
- More walkable
- Higher hazard risk
- Saves $49k
- Similar commute
- Similar walkability
- Higher hazard risk
- Saves $46k
- Similar commute
- More walkable
- Higher hazard risk
- Saves $44k
- Similar commute
- Similar walkability
- Lower hazard risk
Sources
Every number, traced
Every metric above is sourced from public datasets, normalized against the national ZIP distribution. Home values and rents refresh monthly; demographics refresh annually.
Get the HavenScore Weekly
Data-driven market takes and the week's biggest ZIP movers, every Tuesday. Want this ZIP specifically? Save it to your account — saved ZIPs get a monthly digest of what changed.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime.