Saint Augustine, FL · 5 scored ZIPs · September 2026
Saint Augustine, FL: buyers hold the leverage.
Buyers hold the leverage. Listings sit longer and often close below asking. That is the population-weighted reading across 5 scored ZIPs in Saint Augustine, FL. Typical home value $431K, −1.4% over 12 months on average; listings take 72 days to sell against 60 in the median U.S. ZIP.
Saint Augustine, FL5 scored ZIPs
Buyer's market−46
Typical value$431K−1.4% over 12 months, average · Zillow, Aug 2026
Days on market72 daysU.S. median ZIP 60 days · Realtor.com
Listings with a price cut29%U.S. median ZIP 20% · Realtor.com
Typical rent$2,065/mo+1.1% over 12 months, average · Zillow, Aug 2026
Active listings1,463Across 5 ZIPs · Realtor.com
Sale-to-list97.1%8% sold above list, average · Redfin, May 2026
HavenScore53of 100
Average of 5 scored ZIPs, weighted by population · the median U.S. ZIP scores 50
Affordability50
Growth51
Risk46
Momentum68
Livability65
Five parts, weighted. How the score works →
Every ZIP
5 scored ZIPs, each with its own balance and HavenScore, highest score first.
| ZIP | Balance | HavenScore | Typical value | 1-year change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 32092Saint Augustine | Buyer's market −44 | 56 | $464K | −2.6% |
| 32095Saint Augustine | Buyer's market −49 | 56 | $498K | −1.5% |
| 32086Saint Augustine | Buyer's market −46 | 54 | $368K | −1.3% |
| 32084Saint Augustine | Buyer's market −48 | 52 | $349K | −0.4% |
| 32080Saint Augustine | Buyer's market −48 | 47 | $538K | −0.8% |
Market report
What the latest figures say about Saint Augustine.
Over the year to August 2026, typical home values in Saint Augustine fell by an average of 1.4%, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs (based on Zillow ZIP-level data).
Figures for a city or a state are averages across its scored ZIP codes, weighted by population, so each ZIP counts in proportion to its residents. Where only some ZIPs report a figure, the sentence names how many.
In Saint Augustine, the average typical home value stood at $431K in August 2026, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs (based on Zillow ZIP-level data).
In September 2026, the average HavenScore balance in Saint Augustine was −46, in our Buyer's market band, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs.
The HavenScore balance reads signals such as inventory, time on market and the share of listings with a price cut on one scale, from buyers at one end to sellers at the other. A reading below zero favors buyers, and one above zero favors sellers.
How fast homes are selling
In September 2026, the ZIP-level median time on market in Saint Augustine averaged 72 days, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs, against 60 days for the median U.S. ZIP (based on Realtor.com ZIP-level data).
Days on market here is each ZIP code's median number of days a Realtor.com listing spends on the market, from the day it is listed until it closes or is withdrawn, averaged across the place's ZIP codes.
In Saint Augustine, the share of listings with a price cut averaged 29% in September 2026, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs; for the median U.S. ZIP it was 20% (based on Realtor.com ZIP-level data).
Active listings across the 5 ZIPs in Saint Augustine that report them totaled 1,463 in September 2026, according to Realtor.com.
How to read these figures
Each figure names its own month: Zillow's home values and Realtor.com's listings data publish on their own schedules, so the two can sit a month apart. A figure describes that month, not the day this page was updated.
On the map
The 5 scored ZIPs, colored by market balance. Faded dots are nearby ZIPs not in this list.
Skip the map
Loading the map…
BuyersEvenSellers
One dot is one ZIP code; click a dot to open its page. Blue leans toward buyers, orange toward sellers.
Questions about Saint Augustine
Answers from the latest figures, each with its month.
Is Saint Augustine a buyer's market?
As of September 2026, Saint Augustine sits in our Buyer's market band, with an average HavenScore balance of −46 on a scale from −100 (buyers) to +100 (sellers), weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs.
Are home values falling in Saint Augustine?
As of August 2026, typical home values in Saint Augustine had fallen by an average of 1.4% over the previous 12 months, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs (based on Zillow ZIP-level data).
How long do homes take to sell in Saint Augustine?
As of September 2026, the ZIP-level median time on market in Saint Augustine averaged 72 days, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs, against 60 days for the median U.S. ZIP (based on Realtor.com ZIP-level data).
What does a typical home cost in Saint Augustine?
As of August 2026, the average typical home value in Saint Augustine was $431K, weighted by population across its 5 scored ZIPs (based on Zillow ZIP-level data).
Nearby cities
The nearest cities in Florida with three or more scored ZIPs, then the largest of the rest.
- Jacksonville33 mi · 29 ZIPs
- Daytona Beach51 mi · 4 ZIPs
- Port Orange58 mi · 3 ZIPs
- Gainesville61 mi · 9 ZIPs
- Ocala70 mi · 11 ZIPs
- Lake City78 mi · 3 ZIPs
More cities in Florida
- Miami30 ZIPs
- Orlando26 ZIPs
- Tampa21 ZIPs
- Naples15 ZIPs
- Saint Petersburg12 ZIPs
- Sarasota12 ZIPs
- Fort Myers10 ZIPs
- Lakeland10 ZIPs
- Pensacola10 ZIPs
- Tallahassee10 ZIPs
- Boca Raton9 ZIPs
- Clearwater9 ZIPs
Distance is straight-line, between the average position of each city’s scored ZIPs. All 75 cities in Florida →
Sources and freshness
Every figure on this page, where it came from and when.
ZillowHome values, rentsAugust 2026
Realtor.comListings, days on market, price cutsSeptember 2026
RedfinSale-to-list, sold above listMay 2026
HavenScoreScore, balanceScored October 1, 2026
Figures are population-weighted averages of the scored ZIPs listed above.